Blog > Moving Out of Illinois: Real Cost-of-Living Numbers for Indiana, Arizona & Florida
Moving Out of Illinois: Real Cost-of-Living Numbers for Indiana, Arizona & Florida
by
Moving Out of Illinois: Real Numbers for Indiana, Arizona, and Florida
Illinois ranks among the highest property tax states in the country. If you're a long-time homeowner in the Fox River Valley or greater Chicagoland area and you're thinking about leaving, this guide gives you the real comparison — not estimates, not guesses.
The conversation usually starts the same way. A homeowner who's been in their house for 10, 15, sometimes 25 years says: "We're thinking about leaving Illinois. The taxes are killing us."
Then comes the pause. Because wanting to leave and knowing what that actually looks like financially are two different things.
This post is for the homeowners who've made the decision mentally but need the numbers to make it real. We're going to look at three of the most common destination states — Indiana, Arizona, and Florida — and compare them head-to-head against what you're paying in Illinois right now.
Why Illinois Homeowners Are Leaving
Illinois has the second-highest property tax rate in the United States — an effective average of approximately 2.23%. On a $400,000 home, that's roughly $8,900 per year in property taxes alone. On top of that, Illinois charges a 4.95% flat state income tax.
For retirees on fixed income or homeowners watching their kids grow up in other states, the math stops making sense. The question isn't whether to leave — it's where to go and what they can afford when they get there.
Illinois vs. Indiana
The closest move with the biggest tax relief
Indiana is the most common first conversation for Fox River Valley homeowners. It's close to family, familiar, and the financial difference is immediate.
| Category | Illinois | Indiana |
|---|---|---|
| Avg. Effective Property Tax Rate | 2.23% | 0.85% |
| Annual Tax on $350K Home | ~$7,800 | ~$3,000 |
| State Income Tax | 4.95% flat | 3.15% flat |
| Median Home Price (Statewide) | ~$280K | ~$250K |
| Cost of Living Index (100 = U.S. avg) | ~95 | ~88 |
Bottom line: A homeowner paying $8,000/year in Illinois property taxes on a comparable home in Indiana could pay closer to $3,000. That's $5,000 back in your pocket every year — before you factor in the income tax difference.
Illinois vs. Arizona
Sun, low taxes, and a growing market
Arizona has become a top destination for Chicagoland homeowners — especially the Phoenix metro and Scottsdale areas. The climate is the obvious draw. The tax structure is the reason it makes financial sense.
| Category | Illinois | Arizona |
|---|---|---|
| Avg. Effective Property Tax Rate | 2.23% | 0.66% |
| Annual Tax on $350K Home | ~$7,800 | ~$2,300 |
| State Income Tax | 4.95% flat | 2.5% flat |
| Median Home Price (Phoenix Metro) | ~$280K | ~$420K |
| Cost of Living Index (100 = U.S. avg) | ~95 | ~102 |
Bottom line: Home prices in the Phoenix area are higher than Illinois's statewide median — but the tax savings are dramatic. A homeowner saving $5,500/year in property taxes plus nearly 2.5% on state income tax can often offset the higher purchase price within a few years.
Illinois vs. Florida
No state income tax — the number that changes the math
Florida's biggest financial draw is simple: no state income tax. For anyone receiving retirement income, pension distributions, or Social Security, the difference is immediate. Florida home prices vary significantly by region, which means your Illinois equity stretches farther if you know where to look.
| Category | Illinois | Florida |
|---|---|---|
| Avg. Effective Property Tax Rate | 2.23% | 0.91% |
| Annual Tax on $350K Home | ~$7,800 | ~$3,200 |
| State Income Tax | 4.95% flat | None |
| Median Home Price (Statewide) | ~$280K | ~$400K |
| Cost of Living Index (100 = U.S. avg) | ~95 | ~100 |
Bottom line: Florida's statewide median masks wide regional variance — coastal markets run $500K+, while Central Florida and the Panhandle offer significantly more buying power. Your Illinois equity goes furthest when you know which Florida market matches your number.
What would your equity buy in any of these states?
See your estimated net proceeds from an Illinois sale — and what that unlocks as a down payment in your target state. Takes 60 seconds.
Calculate My Equity →The Question Behind the Question
The cost-of-living comparison tells you where you'd save money. But it doesn't tell you what you can actually afford when you get there.
That answer lives in your equity. Specifically — what you'd walk away with after your Illinois sale, after commissions, after closing costs, after payoff. That number is your real budget in the destination state.
Most homeowners who've been in their house for a decade or more are sitting on significantly more equity than they realize. Fox River Valley values have moved. Mortgage balances have paid down. The combination often means the move is more affordable than they assumed.
That's the starting point. Not the state comparison. The number.
How the Sell Here Buy There Program Works
The Sell Here Buy There program is built specifically for this situation. It's a three-step process:
Data note: Property tax rates, income tax rates, and cost-of-living figures are approximate averages sourced from publicly available state and municipal data. Individual rates vary by county and municipality. Home price figures reflect general market conditions and are not appraisals. Consult a tax professional for advice specific to your situation.
Start with your equity. Everything else follows.
Use the equity calculator to see your estimated net proceeds from an Illinois sale — then book a strategy call to map out both sides of the move.